My AntoniaBy: Willa Cather Category: Great Books ~ Novel Guide Created By: Joan Pearson Discussion Leader(s): Maryal and Joan P Click here to visit the discussion
Guide DescriptionA rich evocation through the art of storytelling ~of the Nebraska prairie, the foreign and native-born settlers, particularly of the immigrant pioneer woman, Antonia herself.
Background InformationWilla Cather wrote, "There are only two or three human stories, and they go on repeating and repeating themselves as fiercely as if they have never happened before."
Experience the emotional power of the cruel struggle to tame the raw new country, the Nebraska plains and examine the reasons for the endurance of Cather's story of the losses, the changes, the whole adventure of childhood - as if it had never happened before.
Questions
Introduction
"Life's earliest years for wretched mortal creatures/Are best, and fly most quickly." Virgil
1. Can you find anything on the context of Virgil's quote, "Optima dies...prima fugit"? The choice of this quote is quite appropriate here, don't you think?
2. The introduction begins with an unidentified person, who is Jim Burden's traveling companion on a train. How much can you discover about the identity of this person?
What is the narrator's occupation?
3. What significant information about Jim Burden is provided in the introduction? Is he close friends with the narrator? Why do they not see one another often?
4. Jim Burden writes his memories of Antonia with the original title, "Ántonia". Dissatisfied with this title, he adds "My." This addition seems significant to him. What is the difference between the two titles?
5. What does Willa Cather achieve by turning over the narration of the novel to this fictionary character? Why not tell the story herself?
6. In the first publication the Introduction was approximately four pages, but in 1926, Willa Cather edited it down to two. Most modern editions include the original four pages. Why is the unedited version used today, instead of WC's edited copy? Do you find this strange?
7. Does your edition contain the four-page Introduction in the body of the novel and then the two-page edited version in the appendices? Do you find anything significant edited out of the original?
8. Do you see the significance of opening the novel with an Introduction that is set on a TRAIN? Americans, on the road again? Travelling? What are the implications? "
9. Why did W Cather choose to write a novel rather than write a straightforward account of her childhood in Nebraska?
10. Whose story is it, Jim's or Ántonia's? (Something to think about while reading the novel)
|
For Your Consideration
Chapters I - IV
"At any rate, that is happiness; to be dissolved into something complete and great."
1. What effect did the long train ride to Nebraska have on Jim? Do you see the advantage of making him an orphan? Is there any indication that he is grieving at the loss of his parents? Any signs of homesickness for Virginia?
2. When you compare the attempts of Jim's grandmother and Mrs. Shimerda to adapt to prairie life, do you get the impression that the immigrants will not make it without help from their neighbors? Why do the Shimerda's keep Krajiek around even though they "hate" him? Why does Otto Fuchs really withhold advice to the Shimerdas?
3. Can you find some examples of Jim's keen observations and interest in language and how it is used? He is a reader too. How does Otto Fuchs measure up to Jim's mental image of Jesse James?
4. What causes Jim to feel "entirely happy" in Grandmother's garden? Can you relate to his concept of complete happiness?
5. Why does Jim prefer the legend that the Mormons were responsible for sowing the trails of sunflowers to the botanists' insistence that they are native to the state?
6. After four chapters, do you feel this is Jim's growing-up story, or Ántonia's? At what point does the novel really begin?
7. What passages do you find especially effective in these four chapters?
|
For Your Consideration
Chapters V - X
"...in both of us there was some dusky superstition that those shining groups have their influence upon what is and what is not to be."
1. Have you ever seen as many metaphors and similes in one paragraph as that describing Russian Peter? Is he such an important character? Why does Mr. Shimerda take Ántonia to spend time with these two bachelors?
2. How does Ántonia's description of badger hunting compare with Grandmother Burden's attitude towards the badgers?
3. The chirping of the grasshopper/cricket prompts both laughter and tears in Ántonia who then goes on to tell the story of Old Hata back in Bohemia. How is her story connected to other events in the chapter?
4. Where did Ántonia's father get his rifle? Did you see any significance in his promise to give it to Jim some day?
5. What significance do you see in the snake story? What do we learn about the nature of oral storytelling?
6. Pavel's story of the night of the wolves is one of the incidents in My Ántonia that readers remember years later. How is this story told?
Why do Ántonia and Jim keep it to themselves?
7. Jim and Ántonia curl up together like owls and prairie dogs. Any thoughts on this comparison?
8. What explanation do Jake and Otto offer for the circle pattern from Indian days? What does Grandfather think the Indians were doing? Why does Jim consider this pattern a good omen?
9. The Burden family's way of coping with winter differs very much from Ántonia's. What does Mr. Shimerda tell Grandmother about his family's past? Why does this prevent him from taking better care of his family?
10. How does the language barrier cause the problem with the dried mushrooms? What does Grandmother do with this gift from Mrs. Shimerda? Was this humorous in light of Jim's earlier conclusions about Mrs. Shimerda's reasons for gift-giving?
|
For Your Consideration
Chapters XI - XIX
"...while the herd rejoices in its youth,
release the males and breed the cattle early,
Supply one generation from another. For mortal kind, the best day passes first."
Virgil's Georgics, Book III
1. Does the frontispiece Jim chooses for Yulka's picture book, "Napoleon Announcing the Divorce to Josephine"" seem a strange choice to you?
2. What does Jim's reference to the place from which he brought his Sunday School cards as his "old country" signify to you?
3. What is Jim's response to his grandfather's reading of Matthew's Christmas story? He knows to listen closely to his prayers to find what is on his grandfather's mind. What thoughts are conveyed in this Christmas prayer?
4. Christmas observations reveal cultural differences. How do Jim's grandparents respond to Mr. Shimerda kneeling before the tree, decorated with Otto's Austrian figures? Can you explain grandmother's description of "the talking tree of the fairy tale?"
The January thaw:
5. Does Ántonia's revelation that it was her mother's idea to come to America change your opinion of the Shimerdas? How does Jim view Mrs. Shimerda? How has Ántonia's attitude towards the Burden's changed since the fall?
6. The two old bulls, Gladstone and Brigham Young (why these names?) begin to butt heads, now that it seems spring has arrived. Do you see a connection to the verse from Virgil's Georgics which Willa Cather chose for the epigraph?
7. Who is the more reliable narrator of Mr. Shimerda's suicide, Otto or Jake? What is the coroner's finding? Unbelievable the way his body could not be moved until they located the coroner and a priest.
8. Ambrosch believes that his father's soul is in a place of torment. What does Jim believe? Can you find the source of the "account of Dives in torment" that Jim can't stop thinking about?
9. Has Grandfather Burden changed in his attitudes towards the immigrants? Is he developing a new religious tolerence?
10. Would Ántonia's father have allowed her to forego her education and work the fields? How is she changing? What event comes between Jim and Ántonia? Why does Jim feel he needs to get back at her? How does he do that?
|
For Your Consideration
BOOK II Chapters I - XV
"They were handsome girls, had the fresh
color of their country upbringing, and
in their eyes that brilliancy which is called the 'light of youth'."
1. How does town life in Black Hawk compare with life on the farm
to Jim? To the hired girls? Did Black Hawk/Red Cloud appeal to WC from what you read
here?
2. Do the Harlings seem more clearly defined characters
than others in the novel? What was their importance to Jim/WC?
3. Why did WC include the story of the tramp in
Ántonia's storytelling? What objects do they find in this unidentified man’s pockets? Does
this story fit with any of the others? Do you recognize the tune, Old Oaken Bucket? (Be sure to
enlarge the sheet music here.)
4. In the story of Blind d’Arnault, the Negro pianist who comes to
town, how many stereotypes of black folks do you find? Who is the narrator? What is the
point of this story? Does it tie to other stories?
5. "The summer that would change everything was coming nearer every
day." Does Jim's comment in chapter VIII seem ominous? Did this summer really change
"everything?" How?
6. How did the Dancing Tent disrupt the social order in the town?
Why does Ántonia go to work for the Cutters of all people? What expectations are set up,
given Wick Cutter's history?
7. What do you suppose Frances Harling means when she tells Jim his
problem is that he is a "romantic?" Do you agree with her? What is your definition of a
romantic?
8. Can you contrast Lena Lingard and Ántonia? Why does Lena say she
will never marry? Do you believe her?
9. At the end of chapter XII, Jim tells of a recurring dream he had
that was “always the same.” What observations can you make about this dream? From your own
experience, do you think recurring dreams really mean anything?
10. What additional information do you gain about the hired
girls' past experiences when they picnic with Jim in Chapter XV? What do you make of the
image of the plow against the sun “black against the molten red” that ends this chapter?
11. “The Cutters seemed to find their relations to each other
interesting and stimulating, and certainly the rest of us found them so.” What does this
tell you about the Cutters? About the townspeople? What was Jim's reaction to the near-rape
scene in Ántonia’s bed?
12. What are Jim's observations on married life?
What do you make of the relationships between Mr. and Mrs. Harling, Mr. and Mrs. Gardener
(who run the hotel), Mr. and Mrs. Cutter, Mr. and Mrs. Ole Benson? Are any of these happy
marriages?
13. Does WC get any advantage out of using Jim as the narrator
instead of creating a girl child who was fascinated by Ántonia? Do we need to take the time
of writing (prior to 1918) into consideration?
|
For Your Consideration
BOOK III Chapters I - IV
"She always kissed as if she were sadly and wisely, sending one away forever."
1. How does Jim describe his intellectual awakening? Has he ever had a comparable sexual awakening (that we know of)?
2. What attracts Jim to Gaston Cleric? What does he represent here? Do you believe that a poet can narrowly miss greatness by expending his energies on bursts of "imaginative talk?" Is Jim drawn to follow him into the scholarly life?
3. The epigraph from Virgil’s Georgics appears again. What relationship does Jim see between pretty country girls and Virgil’s poetry? What about those omitted bulls who are carefully not mentioned in this chapter?
4. How would you relate Virgil's "patria" on the Mincio to this story? To Jim's thoughts?
5. How would you explain the tone of the final paragraph of Chapter II? Do you believe Jim will ever be the scholar he is preparing himself to become?
6. What brings Lena to Lincoln and what news does she bring of Ántonia? What is Jim's reaction to the news? What is the name of the game Jim and Lena are playing regarding Jim's feelings for Ántonia?
7. Why does the performance of Camille affect both Jima and Lena so profoundly? Do you know the story? Was there a reason for this second-rate perfomance?
8. Is Cleric's judgment of Lena as "perfectly irresponsible" a fair one?
9. What with all the playgoing and the “delightful Sunday breakfasts,” did you expect a romance between Jim and Lena? Why did Jim decide to leave? What was the significance of his decision?
10. Why does Lena intend to remain single? Do you believe she will? Where have you heard her reasons before?
|
For Your Consideration
BOOK IV, BOOK V "Ántonia had always been one to leave images in the mind
that did not fade— that grew stronger with time."
BOOK IV. The Pioneer Woman’s Story
1. Why is Jim "bitterly disappointed" in Ántonia when he returns to Black Hawk the summer before Harvard? Can you think of other times he felt disappointed in her?
2. Isn't it odd that Tiny Soderball's story is presented here? “[Tiny] was like someone in whom the faculty of becoming interested is worn out." Can the same be said of the adult Jim, the narrator of the novel?
3. What steps does Antonia take to lessen the likelihood that her advancing pregnancy will be noticed? Why doesn't she at least see a dentist about her abscessed teeth? Shame or the expense? What are her feelings towards the child she is carrying?
4. How does Ántonia spend her pregnancy? Does Ambrosch's response to the impending birth fit his character? Does Antonia have support from anyone at this time? Do you think she needs it?
5. Can you explain why, after declaring “I’d have liked to have you for a sweetheart, or a wife, or my mother or my
sister—anything a woman can be to a man,” Jim does not tell Ántonia he loves her and wants to take care of
her?
BOOK V. Cuzak's Boys
6. Why is “Cuzak’s Boys” the title of Book V, when Ántonia has as many daughters as she does sons? What does Jim think of the Cuzaks' marriage? Is it a happy one?
7. How is Ántonia carrying on the tradition of Oral Storytelling? How do the oral stories in Chapter II, the murder of Mrs. Cutter and Mr. Cuzak's life history, fit with the others that are contained in the novel?
8. What has caused Ántonia to return to her Bohemian roots? What happened to immigrant assimilation into American culture? What do you know of Nebraska's "Little Bohemia?"
9. Jim intends to “play” with the Cuzak boys (going hunting and so forth). Even when they are grown up, there will “always be Cuzak himself to play with." Is this the sort of statement a grown man makes? What is it about little Leo that gets Jim's attention?
10. Please share your thoughts on the last sentence of the novel: "Whatever we had missed, we possessed together the precious, the incommunicable past."
| Links My Ántonia ~ ELECTRONIC TEXT
Prairie Plains Talk Sod Houses
Old Oaken Bucket Red Cloud, Nebraska (Black Hawk)
Click here for our Internet Resources for Books
Our readers' guides, created by SeniorNet volunteers, are designed to inform and enhance your reading of specific books that we have discussed on the SeniorNet Books web site.
Permission is granted to individuals and groups for the non-commercial use of
the SeniorNet readers' guides if you attribute them to 'SeniorNet Book Clubs
(www.seniornet.org/bookclubs).' |