Our conversation about Muslims could have taken place, with almost identical statements, throughout U.S. history just with an exchange of ethnic groups. Ben Franklin was condemning of those gutteral speaking, uncouth Germans who continued to speak German in their churches and fraternal clubs and publish German language papers, and those Grman-related activities continued for many generations. The Irish, starting in the 18th century and continuing through many waves of immigration, were condemned as drinking papists, ruled by Rome, not by the constitution. Similar anger was addressed to Italians and we know many are still being branded at first sight, or hearing of their names, as Mafiosa. There are still many German, Irish and Italian fraternities, clubs and celebrations.
As waves of Eastern European and Russian immigrants began to come at the turn of the 20th century and into the 20th century, their "strange" (different from those people already here) language, clothes, food, religions and religious celebrations etc. made them victims of derision and worse. many were labeled as Socialists or Communists who threatened our capitalism, because some of them were, but more so because countries they emigrated from had become thus. Many of them were actually vehemently against those ideologies.
The trend has continued as there are new immigrants or emigration within the country - Blacks, Hispanics, Asians, and now Arabs, Muslims, India-Indians, etc. because they have each been "the other", someone who is different from the general society.
All of us had ancestors who at sometime were "the other", members of the new immigration and not looked on fondly by those already here - even those of us who have ancestors who came in the 17th and 18th centuries.......the Native Americans had many unkind things to say and do about them, including that they were hairy and smelly and knew nothing about how to survive in the wilderness and had only one god!
I just wanted to purport that our conversation is not a new one. It's very typical and should be undrstood from an historical, sociological perspective........... Just the 50 years of being a teacher coming out......