Yes Joan, there are many aspects to Edinburgh!
Alexander McCall Smith is very good at nailing New Town characters - the New Town is full of 'old money', many retired academics, doctors, lawyers, etc. The properties are horrendously expensive so these days only the people who've lived there for years can afford to be there - properties that come on the market are often bought up as investments by the mega-rich. Eventually, I think, McCall Smith-type characters will die out, but at the moment there are still plenty around. The congregation of the Cathedral where I work is full of them! And down in Stockbridge, which is nearby and hugely popular with affluent young couples, there are huge numbers of women like Irene, mother of the hapless Bertie - helicopter mothers obsessed with organic everything.
Ian Rankin somehow seems to know all about the city's criminal side - not sure how, as he's not even from Edinburgh originally, and he's certainly never been a criminal.
His descriptions of night club bouncers, run-down housing estates and seedy shopping malls are all extremely accurate - I can't say whether the rest of it's true to life or not!
I am going next week to the launch of quite a different book - Umbrellas of Edinburgh - in which 70 poets and writers have each been inspired by different places in the city, from Tynecastle football stadium to the Cafe Royale, Blackford Castle and Edinburgh airport. The editors have tried to move away from the typical Edinburgh coffee table book;
'As editors, we were keen to reflect the diversity of Edinburgh and its people, and to shift the existing... focus through a more contemporary lens. This anthology includes work from writers of colour, writers who identify as LGBTQIA+, who live with disabilities, writers who have lived in countries other than Scotland, and its contributors predominantly identify as women.
Our brief to the writers was simple: choose a location in Edinburgh and write about it. Between these pages you’ll find explorations of architecture, fragments of memories, views of potential futures, romps in hedgerows, summer picnics, hard winters, love, loss and the moments in between.'
So it'll be interesting to see what they've come up with.
Rosemary